American Integrity Insurance Group Q4 Earnings Call Highlights

American Integrity Insurance Group (NYSE:AII) executives highlighted sharp profitability gains, continued voluntary policy growth, and a special dividend as the insurer discussed fourth-quarter and full-year 2025 results following its initial public offering earlier in the year.

IPO milestone and full-year performance

Founder and CEO Bob Ritchie said the company completed its IPO in May, raising gross proceeds of $100 million. He characterized the offering as a “catalyst” that strengthened the balance sheet and supported plans to diversify products and expand into new markets.

For 2025, management reported:

• Gross premiums earned increased nearly 30% year-over-year to $885 million.
• Adjusted net income available to common shareholders rose to $103 million, or $5.97 per diluted share, from $37.9 million, or $2.94 per diluted share, in 2024.
• Combined ratio improved to a record 63.7%, compared with 80.9% in 2024.
• Adjusted return on equity increased to 42.1%, up from 26.8% in 2024.
• Customer count grew 19% to nearly 422,000 customers from 356,000.

Ritchie noted that, like other Florida carriers, results benefited from well-underwritten Citizens Property Insurance takeouts in late 2024 and early 2025, but he said the phase of “large, profitable” takeouts has ended. He emphasized that the company’s growth engine is now “organic and voluntary,” supported by agent relationships and underwriting discipline.

Growth initiatives: Florida focus with selective expansion

President Jon Ritchie said fourth-quarter voluntary production totaled 26,025 new policies, bringing full-year voluntary production to more than 104,000, a 17% increase over 2024. Retention improved to 82.7% in the quarter, and voluntary policies in force increased 16% year-over-year to 332,780.

Citizens takeouts were a smaller contributor than in the prior year. The company assumed almost 8,000 Citizens residential takeout policies in Q4, representing $24.2 million of assumed unearned premium, versus approximately 68,200 policies in Q4 2024, with management attributing the decline to fewer policies meeting underwriting and profitability standards.

Executives outlined several growth initiatives:

• Tri-County re-entry: The company reentered Florida’s Tri-County region in Q3 2025 and ended the year with 29,226 policies in force there, representing 7% of the book. Jon Ritchie said the company views the area as underpenetrated relative to its share of Florida households and expects the opportunity to extend into 2026.
• Middle-aged homes: Management said the company is renewing its focus on middle-aged homes after reducing exposure during Florida’s litigation-driven period. Jon Ritchie said underwriting and pricing work has been completed and early production is accelerating, citing legislative reforms passed in 2022 as a factor making the segment more attractive.
• Commercial residential product: Launched in October 2025, the product targets condominium, townhouse, and residential homeowners associations. In Q4, the company assumed 149 commercial residential policies from Citizens, representing $5.9 million of assumed unearned premium, and began writing voluntary commercial residential policies. Management said early results support a measured, “responsible” scaling approach.
• Out-of-state growth: The company reported continued growth in Georgia and South Carolina, largely tied to Florida home builder agent relationships, and noted it has begun writing in North Carolina. Out-of-state policies more than doubled to 26,732 policies in force at year-end 2025, while Florida still represented 97% of in-force premium.

Quarterly financial details and underwriting metrics

Chief financial officer Ben (last name not provided in the transcript) reported Q4 net income available to common shareholders of $20.9 million, or $1.07 per diluted share, and adjusted net income of $21.8 million, or $1.11 per diluted share. Return on equity was 25.6% for the quarter, with adjusted ROE of 26.7%.

Gross premiums written in Q4 2025 decreased to $206.4 million from $237.6 million, which management attributed primarily to fewer Citizens assumptions than in the prior-year quarter. However, gross premiums written in the voluntary market increased to $137.9 million from $122.4 million, and gross premiums earned increased to $229.1 million from $199.8 million, driven by voluntary new and renewal writings and Citizens takeouts.

Losses and loss adjustment expenses fell to $26.3 million from $32.8 million, which management said was primarily due to the lack of catastrophe losses from current-year events. The loss ratio was 42.6% versus 51.6% a year earlier. The company also highlighted a “gross underlying non-cat loss and LAE ratio,” which increased to 17.1% in Q4 2025 from 16.5% in Q4 2024, and noted $3 million of favorable development in the quarter.

Policy acquisition expenses decreased 51% to $5.8 million, and general and administrative costs decreased 43.2% to $6.7 million, which management said was driven by higher non-catastrophe ceding commissions. The expense ratio improved to 20.2% from 37.1%, and the combined ratio improved to 62.8% from 88.7%.

Net investment income increased to $5.9 million from $3.8 million, which the CFO said reflected higher invested assets due to increased premiums in force and IPO proceeds. Shareholders’ equity increased to $337 million at year-end.

Reinsurance, quota share changes, and outlook themes discussed on Q&A

Management said it reduced its non-cat quota share from a 40% cession rate to 25% and renewed the treaty at improved pricing. Jon Ritchie said the company expects the change to reduce quota share cost by about 50% during 2026. He added that in 2025 the company ceded $248 million of earned premium and generated $276 million of revenue; under the new cession rate, management estimated it would have ceded $155 million of earned premium and generated $369 million of revenue.

On the call, executives also pointed to a favorable catastrophe year, noting the company did not experience a catastrophe loss “for the first time in many years.” They said increased global reinsurance capital has improved renewal expectations, citing market commentary that risk-adjusted rate decreases could range from 10% to 20% for 2026 renewals, depending on region. In response to analyst questions, management said it expects its reinsurance buying approach to remain consistent, including third- and fourth-event coverage, and indicated retentions are intended to be consistent with the prior treaty year, while details are still being finalized.

On pricing and mix, Jon Ritchie said the company’s current average rate decrease for 2025 annual rate filings is roughly 5% for its own portfolio, and he said that range appears consistent with broader marketplace trends based on filings and field feedback. He also said mix shifts toward Tri-County and middle-aged homes are expected to lift average premium per policy, while commercial residential growth will take time as the company scales prudently.

Special dividend and capital priorities

The company’s board declared a special cash dividend of $1.02 per share, totaling $20 million. Addressing investor questions about capital management, Bob Ritchie said the company had previously indicated it would consider returning “windfall earnings” to shareholders, citing the absence of catastrophe losses in 2025 as creating surplus capital. He said remaining IPO proceeds are still positioned to fund growth initiatives in 2026.

Asked about buybacks versus dividends, management said it has prioritized building public float and liquidity, citing a secondary offering in the prior quarter and a desire not to reduce float.

In closing remarks, Bob Ritchie reiterated that the company plans to focus on underwriting quality, expense discipline, and “thoughtful yet aggressive” growth, while emphasizing that management believes performance is “durable and repeatable.”

About American Integrity Insurance Group (NYSE:AII)

American Integrity Insurance Group, Ltd. is a specialized provider of personal lines residential property insurance based in Jacksonville Beach, Florida. The company underwrites a variety of policies including homeowners multiple peril, condominium unitowners, dwelling fire, wind-only, personal umbrella and renters insurance. Its product suite is designed to protect against hurricane, windstorm, hail and other weather-related risks common to Florida’s coastal and inland regions.

Founded in 2004, American Integrity operates primarily through a network of independent insurance agents across the state of Florida.